Concerning this:
“We are proud to declare that all WOTLK PVE raid content has now been cleared. This is both a moment of triumph and a cause for concern. The question in all our minds right now is if we could do this, how soon until the rest of the top guilds in the world clear all the raid content that WOTLK has to offer? Did Blizzard miscalculate in the tuning of these encounters? Or is this Blizzard folding under the weight of a large casual player base that demands to be on equal footing with end-game raiders?“
So said the remnants of Nihilum and SK Gaming, who merged to become the Twenty Fifth of November. The actual guild title is TwentyFifthNovember, but such a name hardly rolls off the tongue. Nihilum was a better name, in my opinion.
You know who these are if you keep a small pulse on the WoW Raiding Metagame. Nearly all the world firsts through Black Temple in Burning Crusade went to Nihilum, with SK dominating Sunwell’s progression curve. Happily I’m confident there are people who have never heard of them period. There was a period when I wouldn’t have cared, but now, as Altitis so succinctly stated, I should think it better if people never heard from them again.
I have (or should I say “had?”) respect for the extreme hard-core raiding guild. However, I have also held a doubt as to their actual value in the community. Surely in any human activity there will be people who exceed and surpass the vast majority of those who venture into it–though this has far less to do with ability and more with motivation–and they serve a general purpose of being the paragon for that activity for which others aim. SK/Nihilum have always been very dedicated and exceptional players; for such characteristics some credit and praise is due.
It seems clear now that SK/Nihilum are not exceptional people, as sad as it may seem.
The extreme hardcore have a delirious need to prove themselves to the community. They constantly desire new content to show just how good they are, despite everyone already knowing that already. They suffer from an insecurity we call Pride. Remember how Black Temple sucked because it was rather easy, but Kael’thas was awesome because it was difficult. As was Sunwell. You had to be very good to get into Sunwell. A common slight against Black Temple was “it was a time investment,” not a “skill investment.” How fitting that the self-declared arbiters of good and “skilled” base it around content they’ve already beaten.
Of course, those quotes are all nonsense. All fights in WoW can be beaten in time. Some fights simply require more practice than others, and some guilds are strong in some areas, e.g., healing, that others are not. All fights in WoW are “time investments.” There is nothing in this game that cannot be beaten given enough time put into things. Kael’thas was not “difficult.” Kael’thas strategy was, like all fights, very simple in the theoretical. However, the execution required large amounts of time to get right. The difference in “difficulty” of fights is how much perfection they require. Some fights are aggressively perfectionist, while others are rather lenient. Nevertheless, no guild will ever kill something unless they have the time and energy to do so.
There is nothing “magical” about SK/Nihilum. Their secret lies in time and experience, not in skill. They are quite willing to take off large amounts of time and, according to their own website, “forgo family dinners” in order to get World Firsts. That’s it. They’re willing to put in more time to kill things. Any raiding guild that puts enough time into things will get something down. All Blizzard has done is try to reduce the amount of time needed to do so. TwentyFifthNovember howls at this because it cuts at their false veil of superiority. It wouldn’t do to for people to find out that the “skill” of raiding is all baseline, e.g, stay out of the fire and watch raid announcements, and the only difference between the hardcore and the casual is time and motivation to the learn the dance.
You may notice that very few American guilds take World First kills these days. I can’t remember the last one that did. Why? People make silly arguments about how European or American culture is superior to the other, but they miss the point. WoW is not a terribly skillful game that requires certain character qualities, except the basic ones that apply to all activities: attentiveness, dedication, willingness to listen, teamwork, camaraderie, etc. No, SK/Nihilum have more time than American guilds do because Americans (we can’t forget the Canucks, now can we?
) have a longer workweek and fewer holidays than those east of the Atlantic. The Europeans have more time. Anyone with more time will, in the long run, beat someone at any activity. The pianist that plays for 8 hours a day will always be better than the one that plays for one, even if they have equal talent.
To wit, there is no difference in “skill” between SK/Nihilum and your average guild that only killed Prince in the Burning Crusade. Nihilum had more time. Time and dedication, all of which are nice and wonderful, but they don’t make you superior to any other person. Some people in the world have more responsibilities than you do, and some do not have a society that supports a shorter workweek. The Twenty Fifth of November are just laboring under the delusion that it does, that they deserve more than those pathetically stupid scrubs who never got past Gruul’s.
Of course, that attitude disgusts me, but it shouldn’t. There’s nothing to say about these people anymore. They are, quite simple, irrelevant. They matter no more to the game. They do not, cannot, and will not understand the people who play this game for fun. Falling into, as Lewis said, the “subtlest of all snares,” SK/Nihilum went from playing for fun to playing for playing. No longer having any actual goal behind their actions, they’ve slipped into irrelevance.
We have, of course, said nothing of the fact that SK/Nihilum farmed this content on Beta months before the Expansion actually went live, so this cannot be considered “new” content for them, but their little position is already quaint enough. No need to make it any worse.
We should forget them.





